JustWatch
S04 Episode 1
Falling Down
43 mins · Mon, 2 Sep 2019
S04 Episode 2
Two Families
Unraveling the mystery behind the confusing evidence at the scene of April Holton's tragic murder.
43 mins · Sun, 8 Sep 2019
S04 Episode 3
Twice Shy
Carol-Ann and James Sharp seem like a match made in heaven, but behind the veneer hides a monster in plain sight; loved ones close to the couple sit down for the first time on camera to make sense of a murder that none of them saw coming.
43 mins · Sun, 15 Sep 2019
S04 Episode 4
Life Of The Party
Doug and Rose fall in love and get married; however, lies and deceit surface behind their seemingly perfect facade as seen on home videos; then, a no-show at Thanksgiving and a box on the side of the road lead to a shocking discovery.
43 mins · Sun, 22 Sep 2019
S04 Episode 5
Looks Can Kill
After locking eyes at the gym, Rebecca Thudin and Larry Fenton get married; then, Larry is shot dead in an apparent home invasion; home videos and interviews with family members help to unravel what really happened.
43 mins · Sun, 29 Sep 2019
S04 Episode 6
In Sickness And In Health
When outgoing Beth Spaulding and shy Jason Risenburg meet, it looks like a match made in heaven; however, a series of disasters strike the once-devoted couple, causing tensions to simmer in their marriage.
43 mins · Sun, 13 Oct 2019
S04 Episode 7
Smoke Gets In Your Eyes
When a devastating fire at the Kohnle family home leaves a family member dead, it appears to be an accident. But as the evidence mounts up it's the testimony of two young kids who lead the police to decipher if it was an accident, suicide or murder.
43 mins · Sun, 13 Oct 2019
S04 Episode 8
An Open Relationship
Cassie Golonin disappears just before New Year's Eve from Fort Smith, Ark.; when family and friends conduct a search, the discovery of a shallow grave soon leads to the truth.
43 mins · Sun, 20 Oct 2019
S04 Episode 9
Edge Of Reason
Todd and Rachel Winkler's life looks exquisite from the outside, but inside things are falling apart; video footage shows the truth behind their seemingly happy marriage, revealing terrible secrets and mind games that culminate in murder.
43 mins · Sun, 27 Oct 2019
S04 Episode 10
Double Cross
Four best friends, two married couples, multiple sordid secrets, and one betrayal that leads to murder; with exclusive interviews and never-before-aired home movie footage.
43 mins · Sun, 3 Nov 2019
S04 Episode 11
Momma's Girl
Great-grandfather Arthur Burney knows he's lucky to have such a large, loving family; but when Arthur is found murdered, the entire Burney family is divided - until a tip-off exposes a masterful plot.
43 mins · Sun, 10 Nov 2019
S04 Episode 12
Too Good To Be True
When Amanda Schmitt marries John Grazioli, the happy day is captured on home video; six months later, police respond to a 911 call and make a shocking discovery.
43 mins · Sun, 17 Nov 2019
